Which vegan tacos are better in Chicago: El Hongo Magico or Don Bucio's?
Here’s the quick answer: El Hongo Magico is perfect if you love fresh, mushroom-based tacos with no processed ingredients. Meanwhile, Don Bucio's is for those who prefer vegan versions of classic Mexican dishes, like al pastor and Baja tacos.
Key Takeaways:
- El Hongo Magico: Focuses on whole-food ingredients like mushrooms, offering allergen-friendly, handmade corn tortillas. Best for clean, natural flavors.
- Don Bucio's: Reimagines traditional meat-based tacos with plant-based alternatives like jackfruit barbacoa and tempura-fried mushrooms. Great for bold, creative dishes.
Quick Comparison:
| Feature | El Hongo Magico | Don Bucio's |
|---|---|---|
| Philosophy | Whole-food, mushroom-focused | Vegan versions of classic Mexican dishes |
| Best Dishes | Taco Mágico, Potato & Mushroom Taco | Baja Taco, Jackfruit Barbacoa |
| Menu Style | Simple, natural flavors | Bold, creative twists |
| Dining Experience | Casual food hall setting | Carryout/delivery only |
| Dietary Options | Gluten-free, soy-free, allergen-friendly | Vegan-focused |
Bottom Line: If you want fresh, natural flavors, try El Hongo Magico. For creative vegan spins on Mexican classics, Don Bucio's is your go-to. Why not try both?
El Hongo Magico: Mushroom-Based Tacos
Background and Approach
El Hongo Magico has carved out a unique niche in Chicago's food scene as a taqueria that revolves entirely around mushrooms. Founded by Bernice Vargas Luna, the restaurant takes pride in its whole-food philosophy, steering clear of processed meat substitutes in favor of fresh, unprocessed ingredients. This approach sets it apart from many other vegan eateries.
"We use foods like mushrooms and other vegetables, rather than processed foods like soy, gluten, or meat alternatives. By offering a plant-based menu with no allergens, we can serve more customers with dietary restrictions or preferences. No other taqueria in Chicago can say the same!"
- Founder Bernice Vargas Luna [4]
This dedication to using real, whole ingredients has earned El Hongo Magico a spot on Eater's Chicago's Essential Taco Restaurants list - the only plant-based option to make the cut. Beyond the menu, this philosophy extends to their community efforts, creating a consistent focus on authenticity and simplicity.
"We believe in eating whole foods as part of our plant-based lifestyle and we bring that same vision to our food. You'll always find real food, authentic and delicious!"
- El Hongo Magico Taqueria [5]
Menu Items and Flavors
El Hongo Magico’s menu showcases the versatility of mushrooms with three standout tacos, each crafted to highlight distinct flavors and textures. The kitchen uses a variety of mushrooms, including cremini, portobello, white button, Lion's Mane, and oyster, to create these signature dishes:
- El Taco Mágico: A smoky and flavorful option featuring marinated mushrooms blended with chiles, topped with vibrant red cabbage for added crunch.
- El de Papa: A hearty combination of crispy potatoes, button mushrooms, and poblano peppers, offering earthy tones with a hint of spice.
- El de Rajas: Portobello mushrooms take center stage, paired with tri-color bell peppers and grilled red onions, delivering a satisfying mix of meaty texture and natural sweetness.
Each taco is served Mexican street-style with onions, cilantro, Granny's Green Salsa, and a lime wedge, all wrapped in handmade corn tortillas.
Dietary Options and Allergen Information
Staying true to its whole-food commitment, El Hongo Magico offers a menu designed to accommodate a wide range of dietary needs. The entire menu is free from soy, nuts, dairy, and gluten, making it a haven for diners with food sensitivities. The handmade corn tortillas are naturally gluten-free, ensuring no compromise on flavor or texture. By avoiding processed meat alternatives, the taqueria also eliminates common additives often found in vegan products.
"Our plant-based menu celebrates the magic of whole foods. From our handmade corn tortillas to our flavorful mushroom-based proteins, we're dedicated to creating a menu that's both sustainable and allergen friendly for most dietary preferences and restrictions."
- El Hongo Magico Taqueria [3]
This thoughtful approach to dietary inclusivity makes El Hongo Magico a favorite among families and health-conscious diners seeking clean, delicious, and allergen-friendly meals.
Don Bucio's: Mexican Classics Made Vegan
Background and Vision
Don Bucio's has carved out a special place in Chicago's vegan taco scene by focusing on capturing the essence of traditional Mexican flavors rather than relying on processed substitutes. At the helm is Chef Rodolfo Cuadros, a James Beard Award semifinalist for Best Chef: Great Lakes in 2022, who brings a fresh approach to plant-based dining [7].
"Cuadros explains that most vegan taquerias are obsessed with soy and seitan. His approach is to use vegetables. The concept shouldn't sound as novel as it does... but Cuadros, the former chef at Carnivale in West Loop, wants to give them a thrill." [7]
Chef Cuadros collaborates with Chef Gustavo Ocampo, whose expertise in traditional Mexican recipes and techniques ensures that Don Bucio's stays deeply rooted in Mexican culinary traditions. Together, they strike a balance between authenticity and adaptation, delivering classic street food flavors in a plant-based format.
Popular Menu Items and Ingredients
Don Bucio's takes its commitment to authentic flavors seriously, using inventive methods to craft dishes that appeal to both vegans and traditional taco fans. This dedication has earned the restaurant an 8.0 rating from The Infatuation [6].
A standout on the menu is the Trompo Al Pastor, which reimagines the classic dish with a plant-based twist. Vegetables are processed, frozen into a cylindrical mold, and roasted on a vertical spit to mimic the charred, tender texture of traditional pork pastor tacos. Topped with pineapple, onion, and aioli, this dish is a true labor of love [6][7].
Another favorite is the Baja Taco, a clever take on fish tacos. Tempura-fried portobello mushrooms serve as a "fish taco hack", paired with fresh slaw and chipotle aioli for a perfect balance of flavor and crunch [6]. The Barbacoa, made with jackfruit braised in guajillo chiles, is served in thick blue corn tortillas, which sometimes feature hibiscus for a striking pink hue [6][7].
For appetizers, the Chicharrónes Con Salsa offers a playful twist on pork rinds, with a giant chicharron crafted entirely from fried flour [6]. Chef Ocampo’s Nopal Milanesa is another highlight, combining refritos, crema, pico, arugula, guacamole, and pickled jalapeños for a vibrant and satisfying dish [8].
Restaurant Experience and Community Focus
Don Bucio's doesn’t just deliver on flavor - it creates an inviting and lively dining experience. The spacious, casual interior is decked out with vibrant South Beach-inspired decor, setting the stage for a fun and memorable meal [9].
The restaurant’s service is another standout feature. Staff members are known for their attentiveness and dedication to making every visit special. For instance, when a group of 18 celebrated a birthday in September 2023, the team went above and beyond, offering three complimentary desserts and ensuring the large party felt well cared for [9].
"Great location, spacious and great service. Our server recommended good choices and gave spicy sauce for our needs. Also, she listened to our feedback, which was great." - Rupali K., Yelp Reviewer [9]
With a 4.6/5 rating on Yelp based on 34 reviews, Don Bucio's consistently receives praise for its friendly and knowledgeable staff. Servers take the time to explain dishes, offer recommendations, and even adjust spice levels to suit individual preferences.
"Our server was great! He gave us his recommendations and was very patient with us while we decided what to eat. There was also another young guy there who made our experience even better." - Tree O., Yelp Reviewer [9]
Chicago's BEST Vegan Tacos! #chicagofoodies #chicagovegan
Direct Comparison: El Hongo Magico vs. Don Bucio's
Both El Hongo Magico and Don Bucio's stand out in Chicago’s plant-based taco scene, but their approaches to flavor, value, and the overall dining experience set them apart. Let’s break it down.
Taste and Flavor Comparison
When it comes to flavor, these two spots take very different paths. El Hongo Magico focuses on showcasing the natural qualities of mushrooms, while Don Bucio's leans into reimagining traditional Mexican flavors with plant-based ingredients.
At El Hongo Magico, the taco mágico is a standout, featuring cremini mushrooms marinated in guajillo and ancho chiles, then seared to perfection. This method brings out a smoky depth while keeping the mushrooms tender and juicy. Their potato and mushroom taco also shines, offering a delightful mix of textures.
On the other hand, Don Bucio's takes a bolder approach with its plant-based creations. The asada taco uses forest mushrooms, but the salsa macha can overpower the delicate mushroom flavor. The al pastor taco, crafted from a blend of beans, yucca, and potato, aims to replicate pork but often ends up with a dry, gritty texture. The barbacoa taco, made with jackfruit in guajillo salsa, struggles with consistency, leaning toward mushiness. However, the Baja taco stands out with its crispy tempura and creamy chipotle aioli, offering a satisfying bite.
| Aspect | El Hongo Magico | Don Bucio's |
|---|---|---|
| Philosophy | Highlights natural mushroom flavors | Reinterprets traditional meat-based dishes |
| Texture Quality | Juicy and fresh textures | Inconsistent; some dishes feel gritty |
| Flavor Balance | Subtle and well-rounded seasonings | Heavy sauces can overshadow flavors |
| Best Dishes | Taco mágico, potato & mushroom taco | Baja taco |
| Target Audience | Appeals to a wide range of taco lovers | Geared toward dedicated vegan diners |
These differences in flavor and texture also play into how diners perceive value.
Price and Value Analysis
While detailed pricing isn’t readily available, each spot offers its own kind of value. El Hongo Magico operates in a casual, affordable setting within Uptown’s PlantX Market Food Hall [1]. Its concise menu and approachable atmosphere have earned it a loyal following.
Don Bucio's, which once offered a full-service dining experience in Logan Square, now focuses exclusively on carryout and delivery [10]. While standout items like the Baja taco deliver on taste and presentation, the overall menu can feel hit-or-miss, which may impact its perceived value.
Dining Experience and Location Access
The dining formats of these two spots couldn’t be more different. El Hongo Magico thrives in a shared kitchen environment at PlantX Market Food Hall in Uptown [1]. This setup fosters a casual, community-driven vibe, with flexible hours and the chance to explore other food vendors in the space. It’s a great option for groups with mixed tastes or for first-time visitors wanting a low-pressure introduction.
Don Bucio's, originally known for its full-service restaurant experience, has transitioned to a carryout and delivery-only model [10]. While this shift offers convenience for at-home dining, it loses the in-restaurant ambiance that some diners might miss.
Ultimately, El Hongo Magico’s food hall setting provides a more relaxed, exploratory experience, while Don Bucio's is better suited for those fully committed to vegan dining. These contrasting approaches reflect the diversity of Chicago’s plant-based taco scene, catering to a wide range of preferences and dining styles.
sbb-itb-8621021
Which Vegan Taco Spot to Choose
Main Differences
El Hongo Magico stands out by focusing on the natural flavors of mushrooms rather than imitating meat. Its signature taco, known for its smoky and juicy profile, has won over both vegans and meat-eaters. This creative approach makes it a solid choice for mixed groups or anyone looking to cut back on meat without turning to heavily processed alternatives.
Don Bucio's, on the other hand, reimagines traditional Mexican flavors for a vegan audience. While some dishes, like their take on al pastor, don't always hit the mark, their Baja taco is a clear winner. The restaurant's "For vegans only" ethos underscores its dedication to plant-based cuisine [2].
The differences don't stop at the menu. El Hongo Magico offers a flexible, community-driven pop-up dining experience, while Don Bucio's operates from a full-service location at 2763 N Milwaukee Ave, complete with vibrant decor and attentive service [11].
Bottom Line
Your choice comes down to what you're looking for. If you're drawn to fresh, natural flavors and enjoy a relaxed, pop-up vibe, El Hongo Magico is a fantastic option for both seasoned vegans and those new to plant-based eating. But if you're craving vegan versions of traditional Mexican meat dishes, Don Bucio's - with its standout Baja taco and polished dining experience - might be the better fit.
Both spots bring something special to Chicago's plant-based taco scene. To truly appreciate the range of flavors and styles, why not try both?
FAQs
How do the dining experiences at El Hongo Magico and Don Bucio's compare?
The dining scenes at El Hongo Magico and Don Bucio's each bring something distinct to the table, catering to different tastes and moods. At El Hongo Magico, you’ll find a lively, family-run setting that takes traditional Mexican cuisine and gives it a plant-based twist. Their creative mushroom-based dishes and warm, welcoming service make it a top choice for anyone craving a vibrant sit-down meal.
Meanwhile, Don Bucio's has embraced a takeout-focused approach, perfect for grabbing quick, high-quality vegan tacos. The BYOB policy adds a fun, laid-back element, but the absence of a dine-in option might not appeal to those looking for a more traditional restaurant vibe. Both spots excel in flavor, but your choice depends on whether you’re in the mood for a social dining experience or a grab-and-go meal.
How do El Hongo Magico and Don Bucio's cater to vegan diets and other dietary preferences?
El Hongo Magico: A Vegan Haven
El Hongo Magico takes pride in its all-vegan menu, spotlighting fresh vegetables, handmade corn tortillas, and an emphasis on culinary mushrooms. This spot is a dream for anyone steering clear of processed foods or simply craving bold, plant-based flavors.
Don Bucio's: Gourmet Vegan Delights
At Don Bucio's, a Beard-nominated chef leads the charge with a fully vegan menu that’s as inventive as it is satisfying. Every dish is crafted without meat or dairy, offering a refined dining experience that caters specifically to vegan tastes.
Both of these taquerias shine when it comes to serving up flavorful, vegan-friendly meals, making them fantastic picks for those embracing a plant-based lifestyle.
How are El Hongo Magico's vegan tacos different from Don Bucio's?
El Hongo Magico brings vegan tacos to life by centering their recipes around culinary mushrooms, highlighting their deep, earthy flavors and adaptability in traditional Mexican dishes. Paired with handmade corn tortillas and an array of fresh, colorful vegetables, every bite delivers a wholesome and satisfying taste of authenticity.
Meanwhile, Don Bucio's takes a creative spin on vegan al pastor tacos. Using a vertical spit, they skip conventional meat alternatives like soy or seitan, instead crafting the texture and smoky essence of classic tacos from vegetables. This inventive method offers a fresh perspective for those embracing plant-based dining.
